Like us, dogs have anxieties and fears. A dog’s anxieties may not be the same as a human’s anxieties, but they cause stress and physical reactions just the same.
Some common dog anxiety problems include -
- Separation anxiety – A dog gets anxious when left alone.
- Noise anxiety – A dog becomes fearful and stressed when exposed to loud or unusual noises. Some examples include fireworks, thunderstorms, garbage trucks, and more.
- Travel anxiety – The car is like a den but dogs are unaccustomed to moving dens. Therefore, they may become unsure and anxious over something so new and unexpected.
- Confinement anxiety – A dog gets stressed when he feels trapped or confined. If a threat should arise, a confined dog may feel that he is unable to escape or flee.
Symptoms of Dog Anxiety
When dogs are anxious, they may engage in repetitive or displacement behaviors to relieve that stress. For example, when we are anxious we may pace, bite our nails, or play with our hair.
Dogs may also pace, groom, and more. Some of these behaviors may lead to property destruction, may cause us harm, or may simply be undesirable to our human sensibilities.
Some symptoms of dog anxiety may include -
- Non-stop barking.
- Chewing up furniture, walls, shoes, garbage, and anything else in sight.
- Pooping and peeing in the house, crate or other confinement area.
- Eating his own poop.
- Aggression towards people, dogs, or other animals.
Punishment or aversive techniques will do little to stop these anxious dog behaviors because punishment does not address the source of the behavior, which is the dog’s anxiety. Suppression of these displacement behaviors through pain and dominance methods makes the problem worse because pain will only cause the dog to become even more anxious.
Dog Anxiety Solution 1 – Desensitization
One of the best ways to help a dog deal with his anxiety issues is by slowly desensitizing him to the problem stimulus.
In the desensitization process, we start with a weak version of the stimulus that is triggering the anxiety attack.The stimulus must be weak enough that our dog is able to stay calm. Then we get our dog to focus on us by doing eye-contact/focus commands and other simple obedience exercises.
If our dog is able to focus on us and stay calm, we reward that behavior with a very high priority treat. For desensitization purposes, I usually bust out the really good stuff. I try to pick a highly aromatic/smelly treat that my dog loves but does not usually get to eat. The smell will help to engage my dog’s nose and further distract him from the anxiety stimulus.
If my dog is calm and able to accept treats and interact with me, then I slowly raise the strength of the problem stimulus. I make sure to go very slowly and make each session fun, rewarding, and short.
In this way my dog learns alternative behaviors for dealing with stressful situations. He also learns to associate something that was previously a source of fear and stress with something positive (nice smells, yummy treats), and with being calm.
Dog Anxiety Solution 2 – Calm Environment
Another important aspect of helping an anxious dog is to create a calm environment for him in his daily life.
- Fixed routine – Set a fixed schedule for feeding, walking, play-time, leaving the house, coming home, etc. Also establish some fixed rules and a consistent way to enforce those rules. A very fixed routine and rule-set mean that our dog knows exactly what to expect from us, and also what we expect from him.
- Staying calm - Most dogs are very good at picking up the energy of the people around them. My Shiba Inu, for example, is very sensitive to what I am feeling. If I get stressed and anxious, he picks up on that immediately and becomes anxious himself; but with a hundred times more gusto! Therefore, it is important for us to stay calm and confident.
- Relaxing massage – Some trainers suggest giving our dog a massage to help him stay calm and relaxed. There is also the special TTouch massage method which uses circular finger motions across the entire body of the dog.
I tried the TTouch method briefly on my Shiba Inu but it did not seem to have much of an effect on him. Desensitization exercises together with a fixed and calm routine helped us most.
Dog Anxiety Solution 3 – Calming Equipment
There are a variety of products designed to help calm our dogs. The attraction of such products is that they require little to no work from us. However, it is also unclear how effective they truly are.
1. Dog Appeasing Pheromone (DAP)
DAP is a synthetic chemical that was developed based on a hormone produced by nursing mother dogs. Mother dogs produce this hormone to help their puppies feel calm and secure. It also helps the mother dog establish a positive bond with her puppies.
Scientific studies *do* show that DAP has a positive effect on puppies. However, it is unclear whether DAP helps with anxiety problems in adult dogs.
There are also a variety of natural calming scents including lavender and other herbal remedies.
2. Dog Calming Music
“Music has charms to soothe a savage breast, To soften rocks, or bend a knotted oak.”
Music can certainly help calm us down and soothe our nerves. Therefore, it is not such a big stretch to imagine that it can also be helpful to our dogs. However, the wrong kind of music can actually increase anxiety in dogs.
What is the right kind of dog music?
According to sound researcher Joshua Leeds,
“Rock music, jazz, heavy metal made them more anxious. Classical slowed them down. It just relaxed them in a way that the other music seemed to irritate them.”
The Thundershirt looks like a dog winter coat. It wraps around the torso of a dog, and works by exerting constant pressure on the dog’s body. Proponents of the Thundershirt argue that this pressure can have a calming effect on the dog’s nervous system.
The only scientific study I found on the Thundershirt was a very limited study from an unsubstantiated source. It is unclear whether the claims made on the effectiveness of Thundershirts are true.
Note – Pressure wraps will not work on all dogs. Some dogs may get even more anxious when they experience continuous pressure on their body. In addition, pressure wraps alone will likely not fully solve our dog’s anxiety issues. Wraps and other calming equipment are commonly used together with desensitization and other dog behavior modification techniques, to achieve true long-term success.
Depending on the dog and the situation, you may need to incorporate training with the cape to show an effect. The Anxiety Wrap recommends an 11-step treatment program for separation anxiety that includes using the wrap and leaving toys filled with favorite food treats for the dog to enjoy while you are gone.
Some people also use clocks or heartbeat pillows to help calm new puppies.
Dog Anxiety Solution 4 – Medication
Do not medicate your dog with over-the-counter human drugs on your own. Dogs have very different physiology than humans and dosage is very dependent on weight.
It is important to consult with your vet before giving your dog any medications including over-the-counter human medication.
Some medications used to suppress a dog’s anxiety response include -
- Clomipramine(Anafranil) – This drug was originally developed to treat OCD in humans. With dogs, it is sometimes prescribed to treat OCD and separation anxiety issues.
- Fluoxetine(Prozac,Sarafem,Fontex) – Fluoxetine is perhaps most well-known by its tradename Prozac. Prozac is used to treat heavy depression, OCD, and serious eating disorders (Bulimia nervosa) in humans. Eli Lily makes a special Prozac just for dogs called Reconcile.
For lonely dogs with separation anxiety,Eli Lilly brought to market its own drug Reconcile last year. The only difference between it and Prozac is that Reconcile is chewable and tastes like beef.
- Sedatives – Powerful sedatives such as benzodiazepine (benzo) are prescription only. Some lighter sedatives such as antihistamines (Benadryl) and valerian can be obtained as over-the-counter medications for humans. Do not give sedatives or any other medication to dogs without first consulting with a veterinarian.
The dog medication business is now a very profitable enterprise and there are a large number of dog drugs available for purchase. These medications treat anything from separation anxiety, OCD, and depression, to motion-sickness, forgetfulness, and obesity. Most dog medications are short term solutions and may have serious side effects.
Dog Anxiety Problems
I believe that the best way to help our dogs with their anxiety issues is through desensitization and by providing them with a calm and relaxed living environment.
Dog calming equipment and medication are very tempting solutions because they involve very little to no effort from us. However, their long-term effectiveness is highly questionable. These methods work by suppressing or muting the effects of anxiety rather than addressing the source of the anxiety itself.
This is in contrast with desensitization and home management techniques which target the anxiety stimulus and teaches the dog new ways to cope with fearful and stressful experiences. Rather than just suppressing symptoms, desensitization helps to build a dog’s confidence and promotes a stronger bond between the dog and his human companions.
Ultimately, behavior modification and desensitization techniques lead to long-lasting effects and a better quality of life for a dog and his family.
Dog separation anxiety usually occurs when our routine changes, thereby disrupting the amount of time we are able to spend with our dogs. A dog with separation anxiety may chew up household items, and urinate or defecate in the house, because of extreme stress. We consider dog separation anxiety, [...]
Dog medication is increasingly being used to reduce behavioral issues such as hyperactivity, separation anxiety, and aggression. Is dog Prozac, Anafranil, and various sedatives appropriate for our dogs? Is dog medication effective for dealing with problem dog behaviors? Will it cause more harm [...]
A conversation with my dogs about separation anxiety and why they left vengeance poop all over my carpet. My dogs explain why they get anxious when I leave them alone at unexpected times, and why the vengeance poop is not a pay-back at all, but rather a symptom of anxiety.