If men are from Mars and women are from Venus,
I was curious to see if Martians and Venusians also have big differences in their preferences for dog breeds. Sure, there is the usual stereotype of men preferring larger dog breeds and women preferring smaller dog breeds but is this actually true?
To find out, I decided to collect top dog breed information from Yahoo! Answers.
Here are the five top dog breeds for women and the five top dog breeds for men.
Top Dog Breeds for Women 1
Labrador Retriever
Not too surprisingly, the Labrador Retriever is chosen as the top dog breed by women.
According to the AKC, the Labrador is the most popular dog breed in the United States, and has been so since at least 1997. The Labrador is also the most popular dog breed in the world according to Wikipedia.
This top place is well-earned because the breed is well-temperamented, enthusiastic, attentive, and willing to work. All these qualities make the Labrador a good family member, a loving companion, and a helpful hunting partner.
Top Dog Breeds for Women 2
German Shepherd Dog
German Shepherds are the third most popular dog breed in the United States.
They are self-assured, eager to learn, focused, obedient, and have strong guarding instincts. These traits make them a popular choice for law-enforcement work.
At home, they are a good and loyal protector, but must be carefully obedience trained and firmly handled. Otherwise, the German Shepherd may show dog aggression in his zeal to lead and protect his family.
Top Dog Breeds for Women 3
Golden retriever
The Golden Retriever comes in at a close third after the German Shepherd. In AKC rankings they are the fourth most popular dog breed in the United States.
Like the Labrador Retriever, the Golden is a versatile dog with a gentle and eager to please temperament. Perhaps they are less popular than the Labrador because of their longer coats which need more frequent grooming.
Top Dog Breeds for Women 4
Pit Bull Terrier
The term Pit Bull usually includes the American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier (#68 on the 2007 AKC rankings) and Staffordshire Bull Terrier (#85 on the 2007 AKC rankings).
Pit Bulls have gotten a fair amount of negative publicity which have contributed to their image as a dangerous, and aggressive dog breed. In fact Pit Bulls are banned in some cities in the United States and they are totally banned from some countries.
It is therefore somewhat surprising that Pit Bulls should come in at a strong fourth place, especially among women.
This ranking probably has a lot to do with the Yahoo! Answers population who are more online savvy and who are willing to do the research into the breed and discover that they are actually loyal, fun, and friendly dogs.
“A 2008 study of 6,000 dog owners who were interviewed indicated that smaller breed dogs were more likely to be “genetically predisposed towards aggressive behaviour.” Pit bulls were rated as “average or below average for hostility towards strangers.” ~~[Excerpt from Wikipedia]
Top Dog Breeds for Women 5
Chihuahua
The Chihuahua is 12th on the AKC list of most popular dog breeds (2007). Among the small dog group, Yorkies have recently become the second most popular breed in the United States.
Therefore, it is a bit surprising that the Chihuahua was picked as the most popular small dog breed by the women of Yahoo! Answers. We can only surmise that this discrepancy is due to the poor representation of Yorkie owners in the Yahoo! Answers community. Perhaps Yorkies are commonly preferred by more senior dog owners who spend less time online.
In is unexpected that only one small dog made it onto the top dog breeds for women list. I did not expect to find German Shepherds and certainly not Pit Bulls on the women’s top dog breed list.
The common stereotype that women prefer smaller dog breeds is certainly not borne out by this data.
Top Dog Breeds for Men
- German Shepherd Dog.
- Pit Bull Terrier.
- Labrador Retriever.
- Rottweiler.
- Great Dane.
Surprisingly, the choice of dog breeds among men and women are not that different after all. The German Shepherd, Pit Bull Terrier, and Labrador Retriever made it to the top five in both lists.
Perhaps the most striking difference is that the top dog breeds for men are all larger dogs, whereas the little Chihuahua made it to number 5 on the top dog breeds for women. Perhaps it is not so much that women do not like larger dog breeds, but rather that men have a preference against smaller dog breeds.
The most manly small dog breeds are the Jack Russell Terrier and Beagle.
Top Dog Breeds Data Collection
To collect the top dog breeds data, I did a search on Yahoo! Answers for the keywords “favorite” and “breed”. I then went through each relevant favorite dog breed question, and extracted the answers. When several breeds were listed, I simply picked the first one.
I collected a total of 1064 responses from Yahoo! Answers. 676 were from women, 190 were from men, and another 198 were undetermined because the names, photographs, and profile associated with the answer did not indicate gender.
For the purposes of constructing the lists above, I only used the clearly male and female responses. The undetermined answers were not counted.
An interesting statistic to note here is that the number of female responses is more than three times greater than the number of male responses. This may indicate that women are more active in discussing their dogs. It will be very interesting to see if more women than men own dogs.
border collies rock!
how come you dont have boxers? thry are way better than chiwawas!
The list isn’t based on which dog breeds are best, it’s based on which breeds are most popular.
Back in India we had a Pomeranian. It was really cute and when it died a part of me died with it. I am not sure if I can go through the pain again. Nice info about different breeds.
Yay! a dog *and* anime lover. Yeah I like the look of Corgis too. Shibas actually have a very similar face to Corgis; they are just a bit taller.
For some reason after watching a ton of cowboy bebop I have this love for corgi’s. The giant ears and stubby legs are awesome. I know, it’s not a Man’s dog but they look awesome.
Yes there are 🙂 The basic concept of even identifying dog breed preferences by gender could be considered a stereotype all on its own. The key though is to make sure that there are no negative stereotypes that could be detrimental to any particular group. Hopefully the stereotypes contained herein are all in the spirit of fun and harmless speculation.
Hi Jim, Thanks for visiting. Yes I agree with the both of you that mutts are great dogs. I have had several myself. There was a strong showing for mutts on Yahoo Answers as well; which I think would have been even stronger if the questions were perhaps phrased differently. When someone asks about favorite breed, most people just assume purebreds.
Hi Julie, That is an interesting observation; about women being more likely to respond to surveys. Just from my own experience though it also seems like there are more women in the dog profession. It also seems like there are more women in the dog newgroups that I participate in. It would be interesting to collect data on those things.
Yes I was very surprised too that pitbulls made it to the top 5. I think that the people who are active online are likely to be the ones who are also active off-line with regards to dogs. So many of them probably have rescued pit bulls or have worked with pit bulls. Sadly, there are just very many of them in shelters and rescues.
Thanks for your thoughts and kind words 🙂
I got my family a black lab mixed with chow and whatever else she might be. She is definitely the friendliest dog I have ever seen. She is always excited to see any dog or person.
shibashake, Interesting results. I think women are more likely to respond to surveys. The most surprising was popularity of pitbulls despite the bad press they receive. I still think my favorite is the good old mutt! Interesting topic for a hub. Julie