When to Get a Second Dog, How to Pick the Right One

One common reason for getting a second dog is to keep our first dog company.

The hope is that our dogs can spend their days playing together, and draining each other’s energy. When we come home, they will be happy to lie around, be calm, and be mostly well-behaved. Since the dogs have each other, there will be less need for us to play with them, walk them, or otherwise keep them engaged.

Reality however, is quite different from this idyllic picture.

In my experience, having two dogs is a lot more work than having just one, especially in the beginning. My dogs amp each other up, get more excited together, and lead each other into more trouble than before.

This is not to say that getting a second dog is a bad idea. However, I think that getting another dog for the wrong reasons, will degrade quality of life for everyone in the family, both human and dog.

When to Get a Second Dog, How to Pick the Right One

When to Get a Second Dog?

Make sure that you have good control over your first dog, and that he is mostly well behaved.

Siberian Husky puppy Shania.

I waited for over 1 year before getting another dog. I wanted the extra time to bond with my first dog, properly obedience train him, and make sure I had most of his issues under control.

Only get a second dog when we have good control over our first dog, and have ensured that he is mostly well behaved.

During the first year, I was very tempted to get another dog, as a way to keep my hyperactive Shiba Inu company. Now, I am very glad that I did not do so until both Shiba and I were ready. Having two hyperactive dogs, that were mostly out of control, would have been very stressful for everyone involved.

In addition, issues may arise with the new dog. For example, puppy Shania had issues with her leg, had to go through multiple surgeries, and a leg amputation. I do not think I would have been able to deal with all that, if my other dog were misbehaving at the same time.

I had to spend a lot of time with Shania during her recovery, and did not have as much time for my other dog, but he was totally ok with that for about 5 months.

Therefore, give yourself enough of a time, energy, and financial buffer. If you are starting to feel like you have way too much free time, and that your first dog is sleeping too much, then it may be time to get another. 😀

If you are starting to feel like you have way too much free time, and that your first dog is sleeping too much, then it may be time to get another.

How to Pick a Second Dog

Enjoying a hike in the hills.

What type of dog should we get?

It is always important to get a dog that fits in with our lifestyle, temperament, and energy level. In general, we want to get a dog that has slightly lower energy than we do, and that will enjoy the types of activities that we enjoy.

In addition to all that, a second dog will also have to get along and fit in with the temperament, lifestyle, and play style of our existing dog.

1. Size of second dog.

My resident dog, Shiba Sephy, has a high energy play style. As a result, he frequently overwhelms smaller dogs, and they usually stay away from him during play sessions. He has most fun playing with larger, more boisterous dogs. His favorite breed during supervised play groups, is the Pit Bull Terrier.

I carefully observe my dog while he is playing, and try to identify the types of dogs that he likes interacting with most. In addition to fun, I also identify breeds that my dog shows the most positive and least negative behaviors with.

High-energy, wrestling, play style.

2. Temperament of second dog.

Siberian Shania – Even more goofy than Shiba Sephy.

Husky Shania is food focused and good at obedience.

Being a Shiba Inu, Sephy does not do well with dominant dogs. He likes dogs that are as goofy as he is, and is more interested in playing, than in exerting dominance. While Sephy does not try to dominate other dogs, he will not back down if other dogs try to dominate him. This could ultimately result in a fight.

For a second dog, I made sure to get a puppy that was more submissive in nature.

In addition, the Siberian Husky breed is also known for being affectionate toward people, with a lower protective drive. This balances out my Shiba’s more aloof personality, and his natural watch dog instincts.

In this way, Husky can receive most of the human affection when Shiba is in aloof mode. Similarly, when Shiba alerts to noises around the house, Husky usually just ignores it. Therefore, they complement, rather than amplify each other’s energy.

Husky Shania is also very food focused, and much more interested in doing obedience exercises. After she joined our family, Sephy actually became more obedient because he would come over and participate in training exercises with us.

Siberian Shania can receive most of the human affection when Sephy is in aloof Shiba mode.

3. Meeting and greeting a new dog.

3. Meeting and greeting a new dog.

Do not force the greeting.

How we meet and greet a new dog greatly depends on the temperament of our current dog. In general, it is best for the dogs to meet on neutral territory (e.g. quiet park), so that our existing dog does not get protective over his home turf.

Some things to consider during the meet and greet –

a) Do not force the greeting.

I usually have both dogs on-leash and with separate handlers. Both handlers should be calm and in control. We bring both dogs into the meet area, observe their body language, and how they react to each other. If they seem calm, we try walking them around the park at a comfortable distance.

If all goes well, we slowly bring them in closer together. I observe them closely while doing this, and do not force a greeting if there is extreme stress or signs of aggression.

Like us, dogs are individuals and may not get along with certain other dogs.

Before getting Shania, I looked into adopting a Siberian Husky and had a couple of meetings. However, the rescue dogs got spooked by Sephy, and became stressed around him.

b) Test-drive the new dog.

I first took Shania home for a test-drive week, to see if she would get along with Sephy.

Most good local breeders and adoption/rescue organizations are flexible with the initial try-out period. In fact, they are usually willing to take a dog back, even when things do not work out in the longer term.

After all, everyone wants what is best for the dog.

I first took Shania home for a test-drive week to see if she would get along with Sephy.

Introducing a Second Dog into the Home

After getting a new dog, we want to focus on successfully introducing her into the home. Some of the things that helped my resident dog get along well with our new puppy –

1. Positive experiences. I try to create positive experiences when both dogs are together. In this way, they will see each other as allies.
2. Group obedience training. I have several group training sessions, where both dogs work together for me and get rewarded together.
3. Consistent and fair rules. I make sure that I am consistent and fair with all my dogs. They follow similar rules, as well as receive similar consequences and rewards. I also make it a point to be fair with affection and attention.
4. Rest time. Puppies tend to be on-the-go most of the time. I make sure that the new puppy does not bother my other dogs when they want to rest, or just want some peace and quiet.
5. No stealing. I supervise my dogs closely to make sure they do not steal from each other. Stealing can encourage food aggression and resource guarding issues down the road.

Good luck with your second dog and feel free to share your experiences and questions with us below.

Husky puppy Lara cuddling with adult Husky Shania.